SC rejects election-driven pleas for stay of conviction, grants relief to Azam Khan’s wife, son


The Supreme Court has cautioned against seeking a stay of conviction solely to contest elections or pursue political ambitions, observing that courts cannot allow statutory powers to be used to accommodate electoral schedules.

However, the Court emphasised that judges must carefully balance the consequences of a criminal conviction for an individual’s reputation and dignity against the sanctity of a judicial finding of guilt when deciding whether to suspend a conviction.

A bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu made the observations while allowing appeals filed by Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan and Dr Tazeen Fatma, the son and wife of former Uttar Pradesh minister Mohammad Azam Khan, respectively.

The appeals concerned a criminal case involving the alleged use of two conflicting birth certificates by Abdullah Azam Khan. The bench directed that the convictions of Abdullah and Fatma would remain stayed while their criminal revision petitions are pending before the Allahabad High Court. It also dismissed the Uttar Pradesh government’s appeal challenging the stay granted to Azam Khan.

“We unequivocally disavow and reject any plea that seeks a stay of conviction anchored purely on political expediency, electoral ambitions, or the exigencies of upcoming election campaigns. Courts of law cannot permit statutory powers to be leveraged to suit political calendars or electoral ambitions,” the bench observed.

Reputation and dignity are protected under Article 21

Explaining the consequences of a criminal conviction, the Supreme Court said it can cause immediate and profound damage to an individual’s constitutional right to live with dignity under Article 21.

The bench observed that a conviction can impose severe and irreversible social stigma, moral condemnation and lasting prejudice to an individual’s personal standing and public reputation.

It noted that even if a revisional court subsequently sets aside the conviction on merits, the years an individual spends under the shadow of social disgrace and condemnation cannot be compensated financially or retrospectively repaired.

The Court further said that personal standing, public reputation and human dignity are integral to the right to life guaranteed under Article 21. Their destruction while a bona fide statutory revision is pending could amount to irreparable prejudice.

It added that the discretion available to courts under Section 389(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure must therefore be exercised cautiously, balancing the grave and irreversible consequences of a conviction for the individual against the sanctity that must be attached to a finding of guilt until it is set aside in appeal or revision.

The bench also referred to the Supreme Court’s 2023 judgment in Afjal Ansari v. State of Uttar Pradesh while examining the principles governing the suspension of convictions.

Why the Supreme Court granted relief to Azam Khan’s wife and son

The appeals arose from an Allahabad High Court order dated May 24, 2024. The High Court had stayed Azam Khan’s conviction but declined to grant the same relief to his wife and son, although their sentences had also been suspended and they had been granted bail.

The Supreme Court found that the High Court’s refusal to extend similar relief to Abdullah and Fatma violated the doctrine of parity. It noted that all three had faced a common charge of criminal conspiracy under Section 120B of the Indian Penal Code, based on the same documentary evidence involving two birth certificates issued in Rampur and Lucknow.

The bench observed that no distinct act of manual forgery had been individually attributed to Abdullah or Fatma beyond their alleged roles as co-conspirators and beneficiaries.

It held that, given the identical evidentiary foundation and conspiracy allegations, granting a stay of conviction to Azam Khan while denying the same relief to his wife and son amounted to arbitrary differentiation.

Consequently, the Supreme Court allowed their appeals and directed that the trial court’s conviction order dated October 18, 2023, as affirmed by the appellate court on December 23, 2023, would remain stayed for Abdullah and Fatma during the pendency of their revision petitions.

The State of Uttar Pradesh’s appeals challenging the relief granted to Azam Khan were dismissed. The High Court has been asked to decide the pending revision petitions on their individual merits, without being influenced by the Supreme Court’s observations, and as expeditiously as possible.

The case concerns allegations that two birth certificates were obtained for Abdullah Azam Khan. The family members were convicted by a trial court in October 2023 and sentenced to seven years’ imprisonment. The Supreme Court’s latest order concerns the interim stay of their convictions while the criminal revision proceedings continue.

Latest Posts

Don't Miss

Bajaj Finserv Intelligence, Pennant back AI startup Soket AI with $4 mn | Industry News

Bajaj Finserv Intelligence and Pennant Technologies have together invested nearly

BJP Leader Devji Bhai Patel Accuses Congress of “Anti-Sanatan” Politics Over Remarks on Jagadguru Rambhadracharya

Raipur, Chhattisgarh — Senior BJP leader and former MLA Devji

Law Triumphs: Accused Sentenced to 10 Years Rigorous Imprisonment in Culpable Homicide Case

Raigarh । Under the strong leadership and direction of Police

GeM: A Model Platform for Inclusive and Transparent Government Procurement

By Piyush Goyal, Union Minister for Commerce and Industry The